Are you trying to decide between Xfinity TV and Verizon Fios TV? As leading cable TV providers, both offer strong channel lineups and features. But there are key differences to understand before choosing the best option for your home.
This comprehensive guide compares Xfinity and Fios on pricing, contracts, fees, channel selections, sports offerings, DVR capabilities, and more. I evaluate the pros and cons of each service to help you make an informed decision.
After extensive research and first-hand experience with both providers, I break down how Xfinity and Fios TV stack up across critical categories. Read on to see which is the better fit for your viewing preferences and budget.
Introduction to Xfinity TV and Fios TV
As two premier cable TV services in the US, Xfinity TV and Fios TV offer robust channel selections with 100+ options even at entry-level tiers. Both provide access to popular national networks along with regional sports coverage, on-demand libraries, intuitive program guides, and advanced DVR capabilities.
Xfinity TV is the TV service from Comcast, the nation’s largest cable provider. It uses a combination of fiber and coaxial cable to deliver crystal clear HD quality across an extensive range of packages:
- Offers 125+ to 200+ channels depending on your location
- Access to premium channels like HBO and SHOWTIME
- Updated X1 platform for seamless viewing experience
- Voice remote and smart home integration
Meanwhile, Verizon Fios TV utilizes 100% fiber optic technology to enable sharp video and minimal buffering. As an ultra high-speed internet and TV provider, Fios stands out with:
- Up to 425+ channels available
- Fios TV One box with voice control
- Stream on multiple devices in and out of home
- Six FiOS TV One multi-room DVR
Both Xfinity and Fios continue to expand their channel offerings and capabilities to meet customer demand. While they take different approaches, each aims to provide a modern TV solution with broad programming diversity at reasonable prices.
Next, let’s look at each service’s availability since that may dictate which options you can actually choose between.
Availability and Service Area Comparison
The first factor to consider is whether Xfinity or Fios TV services your location. Since both providers have extensive infrastructure build-outs but regional restrictions, double check access where you live before proceeding.
Xfinity TV Availability
As the nation’s largest TV and Internet provider, Xfinity TV covers over 100 million homes nationwide. It’s widely available across 40 states, especially concentrated along both coasts and the Midwest:
- Greatest coverage across Northeast corridor and Pacific regions
- Expanded availability through rural buildouts
- Check by exact address to confirm Xfinity services your area
Fios TV Availability
Since Verizon Fios depends on specialized fiber optic cabling, its TV footprint is smaller by comparison. Fios home TV service extends to only 9 states at this time:
- Concentrated in Mid-Atlantic and Northeast
- Covering nearly 7 million homes
- Use online address tool to verify Fios services your neighborhood
While Xfinity may be the default choice for many given its larger reach, Fios remains competitive in offering a compelling TV product where available. Be sure to start your comparison search by validating accessibility for both providers based on your address.
Xfinity vs Fios TV Pricing
When weighing Xfinity vs Fios TV, pricing often emerges as a deciding factor for budget-conscious shoppers. Let’s break down what each service charges across base packages, premium add-ons, equipment fees, and other recurring costs.
Base Package Pricing
Both providers balance channel count with affordability across tiered plans suitable for light and heavy TV viewers. While bundles yield the best overall value, you can purchase TV as a standalone service as well.
Xfinity TV Plans and Pricing
Xfinity TV offering start at $50/month for the 125+ channel Popular TV plan. For more content, upgrade to the Ultimate TV plan with over 185+ channels for $70/month.
- No contracts so you can downgrade or cancel anytime
- Entry-level package has major networks like ESPN, Fox, and MTV
- Upgrade for more sports, movie, and entertainment options
- Actual pricing varies slightly by region
Fios TV Plans and Pricing
Fios TV begins at $85/month for the 125+ channels Your Fios TV plan. From there, pay extra for more comprehensive selections up to the 425-channel Most Fios TV package at $129/month.
- No annual contracts or early termination fees
- Baseline tier has favorite channels like HGTV, Food Network
- Progressively larger lineups as you move up tiers
- All packages include primary local channels
Based solely on base pricing, Xfinity TV holds the edge for budget-focused viewers that still want robust programming. But channel preferences and availability ultimately determine which provider to choose if cost is a driving factor.
Premium Channel Add-Ons
Both Xfinity and Fios enable you to supplement base packages by purchasing premium channels individually or as part of special packages. This is where Fios pulls ahead in terms of high-end value if your priority is maximizing content.
Here’s a side-by-side look at what each platform charges for the top-tier premium channels:
| Premium Channel | Xfinity TV | Fios TV |
|---|---|---|
| HBO + HBO Max | $15/month | Included at Most Fios tier |
| Showtime | $12/month | Included at Most Fios tier |
| Cinemax | $12/month | $15/month |
| STARZ | $9/month | Included at Most Fios tier |
| EPIX | $6/month | $11/month |
Additionally, Fios gives you steep discounts when you bundle multiple premiums. For example, get all 5 major channels for just $40/month compared to over $50 individually through Xfinity.
Clearly Fios promotes greater premium channel flexibility, especially if you opt for one of the higher-end packages. Consider this appeal if HBO and Showtime carry weight in your provider decision.
Taxes, Fees and Surcharges
While essential to tally in your total cost projections, taxes, fees and surcharges vary too much by location to provide universal comparison points. However, we can spotlight how Xfinity and Fios generally handle add-on pricing.
Xfinity TV Fees
- Regional sports fees – up to $18/month
- Broadcast TV fees – up to $25/month
- Set-top box rental – $10/month per box
- DVR service – $10 to $20/month
- Early termination fees – up to $360 if you cancel completely within 2 years
Fios TV Fees
- Set-top box rental – $12/month per box
- DVR service – $12 to $25/month depending on DVR storage
- Fios router rental – $15/month
- Early termination fees – None since it’s contract-free
The unavoidable reality is that fees, surcharges and hardware rentals will tack on $15 to $50 extra per month for either service. Estimate high when budgeting so these incidentals don’t catch you off guard.
Contract and Cancellation Policies
Mercifully, you won’t face painful contracts or early termination fees from switching providers anytime soon with Xfinity or Fios TV. Both function on a month-to-month basis with convenient cancellation policies.
Xfinity TV requires 30 days notice before your next billing cycle ends if you decide to cancel service altogether. This grants flexibility to change packages or leave entirely free of penalties.
Likewise, Fios TV commitments run monthly so you can downgrade, pause or disconnect whenever you want. Return equipment promptly when cancelling to avoid additional device non-return fees.
For households that may move or want provider flexibility year-to-year, the contract-free nature of both Xfinity and Fios TV keeps long-term costs predictable.
Xfinity vs Fios Channel Lineups
With pricing and contracts covered, let’s explore the critical issue of channel packages and programming options that each service delivers.
While both feature admirable depth at all levels, Fios nudges ahead for households wanting maximum variety across entertainment genres, sports interests, premium channels, and niche offerings.
Local Channel Availability
Firstly, you’ll be pleased to know that all core packages from both Xfinity and Fios TV include major local network affiliates. That means easy access to ABC, CBS, NBC, Fox, PBS and other regional favorites broadcasting news, events, and shows focused on your metro area.
Some key points about local channel availability:
- Get all the expected local news, weather, and network shows
- Broadcast in high definition where available
- Certain blackout rules and exclusions occasionally apply for live sports
So if watching local programming is a priority, rest assured you’ll have those familiar stations covered through either provider’s base plans as a minimum.
Sports Channel Options
For avid sports fans hungering to follow favorite teams and leagues, channel selection can make the difference between an enjoyable season and one filled with unpleasant coverage lapses.
Both carry baseline channels like ESPN, FS1, TBS plus a smattering of league networks. However as you would expect, channel count and crossover between pro sports, college conferences and niche leagues varies between providers.
Xfinity TV Sports Channels
- 125+ channel Xfinity plan includes ~10 core sports networks
- Upgrade to the 200 channel tier to add NFL Network, MLB Network and more
- Comprehensive options but trails Fios at high-end
Fios TV Sports Channels
- Entry-level Fios plan has 15+ sports networks
- Progressively more channels for MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL and others at higher tiers
- Up to 40 total sports channels available; upside and depth favored
Based on pursuing diverse sports programming for avid fans, Fios TV provides a more well-rounded selection. While Xfinity satisfies general access to mainstream pro leagues, Fios opens doors for college sports and specialty niche channels.
Premium Movie Channels
For movie lovers looking to replicate the cinema experience at home, choosing a provider capable of delivering premium channels is a sensible move. And studios like HBO, STARZ and Showtime offer new releases and originals in real-time alongside classic films.
In this category, advantages again tilt solidly towards Verizon Fios thanks to more flexible pricing models and deeper movie channel penetration even at mid-tier programming.
Xfinity Movie Channels
- HBO and Cinemax start at $15/month each
- Showtime, STARZ, EPIX sold separately ($6 to $12 range)
- Total cost for top five nearing $70/month
Fios TV Movie Channels
- HBO, Showtime and STARZ included at $120+ package
- Optional Cinemax and EPIX add-ons
- All five premiums offered at reduced $40 monthly fee
- More cost efficient, especially for premium tier shoppers
For movie and entertainment enthusiasts wanting to economize on premium channels, Fios TV’s high-end bundling proves extremely enticing. Expect to pay far less gaining equivalent big studio access compared to mixing and matching add-ons through Xfinity.
International and Niche Channels
Beyond mainstream American programming, what about underserved international audiences or niche markets like classic comedy and arts?
Any competitive TV provider recognizes the need to court diverse viewer demographics through expanded channel options. Here Xfinity makes modest forays with a few dozen international and specialty offerings available.
However Fios TV once again shows greater purpose in casting a wider, more inclusive programming net for subscribers, with over 140 global and niche channels to complement its traditional American networks.
Some interesting channels offered through Fios but not Xfinity encompass:
- International networks like TV Japan, Filipino Channel, GMA Pinoy
- Niche arts and culture channels like History en Espanol
- Classic TV channels like Game Show Network, Buzzr, MTV Classic
For specialized interests beyond the usual comedy, drama and reality show spheres, Fios TV opens more avenues to satisfy eclectic viewing tastes.
DVR Functionality and Storage Options
DVR services enable you to record programming like news reports, sports events and season finales to watch on your own schedule. Xfinity and Fios both incorporate cloud DVRs with ample storage along with key playback functions to skip commercials or access recordings remotely.
Let’s examine the DVR-related capabilities of each TV provider in greater detail:
Xfinity X1 DVR
- Includes 20 hours HD storage
- Upgrade to 150+ hours for $10/month
- Store shows for indefinite amount of time
- Manage via My DVR online portal
- Record up 6 shows simultaneously
- Watch DVR recordings anywhere
Fios TV DVR
- Get 100 hours HD storage free at top-tier plan
- Upgrade to 200 hours for $15/month extra
- Store shows indefinitely
- Online DVR manager portal
- Record up to 12 shows simultaneously
- Out-of-home streaming capability
For a robust cloud DVR included, the Fios TV DVR holds a slight edge thanks to more storage without paying extra. But both represent industry-leading solutions packed with convenience and flexibility for time-shifting shows.
Xfinity vs Fios: User Experience and Equipment
In terms of day-to-day viewing, ease of discovery and seamless navigation make all the difference separating a frustration-free experience from one plagued by complexity and unfamiliar menus.
Thankfully Xfinity TV and Fios TV models excel in this department, each consolidating access to linear TV, On Demand libraries and streaming apps into unified interfaces. One difference is Fios provides the same platform whether you watch on a big screen or mobile browser.
Let’s examine some other similarities and differences related to UI and equipment between services:
Xfinity X1 Platform
- Intuitive consolidated guide to live, Cloud DVR, apps
- Available for TV boxes, mobile devices and browsers
- Voice remote control standard
- Cast to multiple TV boxes + streaming flexibility
- Excellent search and robust recommendations
Fios TV One Platform
- Unified viewing guide across all devices
- Multi-regional voice remote with shortcut buttons
- Cast DVR recordings stored in cloud to any device
- Stream outside the home; download recordings
- Universal search; closed captioning; video descriptions
Both achieve excellent consistency bridging live TV with streaming functionalities across supported devices. Fios holds an edge accessing cloud recordings externally, but the overall experience quality feels on par.
One last differentiator is the initial equipment delivery and setup process which favors Xfinity for a quicker, DIY experience:
- Xfinity X1 self-installation kit, live chat guidance if needed
- Fios technician completes standard pro install, up to 4 hours
Assuming the appointment timing works for your schedule, the one-time Fios installer visit shouldn’t hamper an otherwise superb viewing experience. Just account for tech availability when ordering so operations disruptions are minimal.
Internet Bundles and Package Deals
While so far I’ve focused exclusively on analyzing core TV products, Xfinity and Fios incentivize bundling TV with Internet or mobile phone service. This helps lower pricing through discounts off standalone plans.
Briefly, benefits for existing customers or new subscribers choosing bundled packages include:
Xfinity TV Bundles
- Internet + TV bundles from $70 to $200/month
- Mix-and-match Flex 4K streaming also available
- Multiple promos like discounted first year rates
Fios TV Bundles
- Fios Gigabit Internet + TV bundles from $85 to $180
- Match Internet speed tier to your usage needs
- Order Fios Home Internet and TV online even as new customer
Generally Fios overtakes Xfinity on Internet performance thanks to dedicated fiber lines capable of multi-gigabit speeds. But both excel at pairing TV with complementary services for convenience and savings up to $500 over two years.
Xfinity vs Fios: Which TV Service is Best?
stacking up core differences across availability, pricing, channels, DVR functionality and more, Fios TV prevails as the superior overall cable TV service…where accessible.
The uncompromising combination of widespread HD channels (400+ available), full-featured voice remote, Zero buffering, and free premium channels (HBO, Showtime) bundled into higher plans makes Fios hard to beat for experienced television fans. Plus enjoy modem equipment with 6 tuners and your DVR loaded with 200 hours of HD storage out the gate.
However, Xfinity provides a compelling alternative for budget-focused subscribers still wanting good channel variety and an easy-to-use interface. Lacking extensive sports and niche channels compared to Fios holds Xfinity back somewhat for discerning viewers. But with far wider regional availability at competitive rates, Xfinity TV works well for casual to moderate TV usage despite lacking Fios’ overall polish and programming depth.
Below I break down the advantages holding Fios ahead as the better premium cable TV service balanced against why Xfinity TV still warrants consideration:
Key Fios TV Advantages
- Wider channel selection with 400+ available
- Competitive base pricing plus cheaper premium bundles *contract-free so no ETF worries
- Smoother streaming, quicker response times
- More simultaneous DVR recordings; 200+ hour base storage
Xfinity TV Strengths
- Double the regional availability
- Slightly lower base package rates
- DIY self-setup kit for fast installs
Given Xfinity’s position as one of the largest cable providers comparable to DirecTV, Fios has done an admirable job keeping pace in markets where available. However, wireless competitors like YouTube TV also pressure Xfinity while Dish TV merges with DirecTV.
FAQs
Does Xfinity or Fios offer better HD quality?
Fios TV generally provides better HD picture quality thanks to the end-to-end fiber network. Expect minimal buffering, faster response times when scrolling through guides, and vivid colors. Xfinity HD still looks great but can suffer intermittent hiccups.
Which is better for sports fans wanting lots of game and league channel options?
Fios TV wins for sports fans hands down. Diehard fans can access niche sports networks like NFL Redzone along with major pro leagues. Fios offers 40+ sports channels compared to just 20-25 with Xfinity TV across opens, hockey, racing and more.
Do Xfinity and Fios carry local regional sports networks?
Yes, both feature popular RSNs like NBC Sports Philadelphia and NESN that broadcast local MLB, NBA, NHL and other pro team games unavailable on national networks. Some blackout restrictions apply so verify channel access in your area first.
Can I access all the same On Demand movies and shows?
The Xfinity Stream app and Fios TV One app both offer extensive libraries with tens of thousands of On Demand titles to choose from. Expect at least 80% commonality for new release movies and current hit cable series. Fios also enables downloading DVR recordings to mobile devices.
Which offers better customer service and satisfaction ratings?
Independent research firms give Fios TV strong marks for service quality and support responsiveness. With extensive fiber infrastructure backing the TV product, Fios rates well for minimal buffering, reliable uptime and issue resolution. Xfinity posts average to slightly above average ratings among leading cable competitors.
Key Takeaways
- Fios TV tends to offer larger, more diverse channel packages through tiered plans up to over 400 channels. Xfinity tops out around 200 channels on premium plans.
- Base Fios package pricing holds steady with Xfinity’s offerings. But Fios discounts premium channels added in bulk while Xfinity individually prices each premium network.
- Xfinity TV enjoys more widespread regional availability, servicing nearly 3X as many households as Fios nationally. But Fios actively expands to additional neighborhoods when possible.
- In terms of technical capability, Fios TV’s fiber-backed platform enables faster response times, quicker channel changes and less intermittent buffering.
- Both provide contract-free service allowing convenient cancellation or changes anytime. Return equipment promptly to avoid non-return fees.
- For sports enthusiasts, Fios TV unlocks substantially more niche sports programming across golf, tennis, soccer and college conferences.
- Fios edges Xfinity for HD quality, overall customer satisfaction and support response rates based on industry research.
Bottom line – Fios and Xfinity both deliver superb cable TV experiences. Fios wins out where available thanks to faster fiber speeds, more HD channels unlocked on higher plans and a sports-friendly programming slate. But Xfinity merits consideration for high reliability and a more economical mainstream package suited for casual viewers.
